Yankee candle vs Bath and Body Works, which of these is the better one?

Yankee candles and Bath & body works are scented candles made of fragrance oils and other ingredients. They work as aromatherapy candles to aromatize your home and make you feel relaxed and calm. They may also help you feel energized by diverting your mind towards more productive thinking and work. Yankee candles have natural ingredients that burn slowly and last longer with a scent not too sharp. 

Let’s compare them and find out how they differ from each other, with pros and cons.

Yankee Candle Vs. Bath & Body Works: What Is The Difference?

Yankee candles started business in 1969 when a 16-year-old boy melted some crayons to make a gift for her mother at Christmas. After that, he never looked back and started making different types of candles by creating a small business.

Today, they are operating 309 active stores both in U.S and Canada. BBW candles, on the other hand, started back in 1990 as a local candle retailer, and since then, it has grown to become an international brand with more than 1900 worldwide outlets. No doubt both these companies sell the best candles, but there is still some difference between their products at some point.

Yankees not only sell body care items or hand sanitizers but also manufacture and sell products that make your homes and vehicles smell fresh and pleasant. They make many scented candles available in more than 600 options and even come in seven different size options for your choosing (check the top rated Yankee candles). 

Apart from candles, Yankees also sell fragrance diffusers, reed diffusers, scent plugs, scent lights, three different types of wax warmers, room sprays, and fragrance tins made from gel. Further, they even deal in some candle accessories like candle trays and holders.

Body & Bath Works, on the other hand, are not just limited to selling candles. Their line of products further includes body care items like body lotions, gels, lip moisturizers, hand creams, body sprays, and much more. 

Furthermore, they continued into a wide selection of hand sanitizers and hand or body soaps with car and room fresheners. The candles they make mostly contain three wicks or a single wick considering the needs of their customers. 

Yankee Candle’s Scent Categories:

When compared between the categories of their scent, there isn’t much difference between what these two candle brands offer. The Yankee candles have Fruity, Floral, Citrusy, Clean and Fresh, Sweet and spicy with Woody scent. The BBW candles also have a similar category: Floral, Fresh, Citrus, Sweet, Spicy, and woodsy. Yankee has more than 220 plus fragrance candle categories that are all equally popular. These candles are all excellent for mindfulness which helps you to relax and also clear your head.

Yankee candles contain Paraffin Wax as the main ingredient that combines essential oils of fragrances and wicks usually made of cotton. Unlike BBW candles, they are not vegan, but this still doesn’t make them mostly Eco-friendly. Therefore, they are not entirely safe in ingredients and might also be harmful under particular conditions for some people. 

Bath & Body Works Categories:

The BBW offers candle products in all six categories in the fragrance industry. They include Fruity, Citrus, Fresh, Floral, and Sweet like Gourmand and Woodsy candle categories. Their candles are of two different types, Vegetable, and Paraffin wax, as used in Yankee candles. Paraffin contains petroleum-based wax made with slack wax which includes high oil levels. This oil is refined, which decreases the presence of oil content to become Paraffin wax. 

When these chemical-based candles burn, they emit hazardous chemicals like toluene and benzene, which cause different health issues, some of which are very serious. 

To summarize, burning a Paraffin candle is just like lighting up fossil fuels at your home, which is safe for yourself and the surrounding environment. For candle production, this wax is added with synthetic glosses, fragrances, colorants, chemical fixatives, wire or cotton, and woods with cotton wicks.

The Vegetable wax candles, on the contrary, do not contain vegetable oils in actuality but rather have plant oils like coconut, soy, sunflower, palm, and many more. These plant oils are then hydrogen gas and converted into saturated fatty acids. When added with other ingredients, these fatty acids have higher melting points and become vegetable wax for these different candles. 

Yankee Candle Vs. Bath & Body Works: Candle Comparison:

Yankee and BBW have similarities in how they make their candles. Candlemakers located in Central Massachusetts mostly make these Yankee candles. They even opened a production unit in the Czech Republic to easily distribute their products in Central Europe. 

The components used to make Yankee Candles are top-quality paraffin or soy wax with scented ingredients. Each candle has a top, middle, and bottom note to its smell with a mixture of different components. Yankee candle wicks vary in color combination and fragrances, but their material is mostly 100% natural fibers. 

Every candle burns differently from each other; therefore, some may even have 100% cotton wicks or even cotton sealed in paper cores with wax layers around them. They make candles with different fragrances available in different colors and sizes within each class. 

The BBW candles, however, are all manufactured in the U.S despite the fact they resource raw materials from different parts of the world. These candles are available in many varieties made with highly concentrated fragrances, including essential oils. BBW candles are mainly a blend of soy-based wax in melted form with a burn time of around 45 hours for their three-wick candles. Their single-wick candles have a lower burn time of approximately 25 hours; however, all these candles are lead-free.

In addition, these wicks vary by color combination and fragrance scent, but the materials are 100% natural fibers. Their fragrances come with decorative lids to retain the fragrance intensity when not in use. BBW candles are mostly seasonal-based with trendy colors and memorable scents that never lose their charm and effect whenever used.

Pros and Cons of Yankee Candle

The Jar of Yankee candles represents their brand's long commitment to creating excellent fragrances that are widely popular and well known worldwide. In its premium refined form, paraffin wax is the most common and main ingredient substance they have used in their candle making. In addition, the fiber wicks they use are natural, with a solid assurance that they will be the best burn candle with zero toxic substances.

Below are some of the Pros and cons of Yankee candles.

Pros:

- Different themes are available in candles

- Wide range of above 600+ different types and seven sizes

- Festivals or occasional uses candles are also available

- Pure 100% Cotton made candles are lead-free 

- Comes in jars with recycling options for various uses

- A true-to-life scent most loved by their customers

Cons:

- Still very expensive despite the performance and variations

- The complete ingredient list is not shown; it might be dangerous for some people

Pros and Cons of Body & Bathe Works:

Although very popular and highly liked throughout the world due to their top-notch fragrances, these candles still lack in few things below. Check out the pros and cons below to learn more about them before purchasing.

Pros:

- Fragrances are robust due to essential oils added with chemicals

- Quickly fill the room, and you can smell them the moment you enter

- The three wicks help to melt the candles evenly 

- Pleasing and attractive packaging both inside and outside

- Long-lasting for up to 45-25 burn hours

Cons:

- Contains different chemicals and ingredients that are hazardous to health

- Very expensive, especially outside the U.S

Yankee Candle Vs. Bath & Body Works: Which One to Choose

Choosing between Yankee or BBW candles might be a little difficult if you cannot differentiate between them in terms of their features. However, with enough information, such as below, we believe you might easily make the right decision by keeping your needs at the top.

Choose Yankee Candles Only When:

- You are looking for a wide range of different varieties

- You want different sizes of candles

- The candle should burn slowly with a more prolonged scent effect

- You want quality candles at affordable prices

Choose Body & Bath Works Candles Only When:

- Your priority is a solid aromatic scented candle

- Changing the candles often works fine for you

- You want a simple-looking candle 

Body and Bath candles have a much stronger scent than Yankees; however, their burnout time is also faster. This probably might not be an issue for some customers, but this way, you will spend more on candles through frequent buying than Yankees.

When it comes to Yankee candles, the company offers many scents to choose from, and their burnout time is also slow. Therefore these candles last long; however, the fragrances in some candles are not very strong and up to quality, especially when compared to Body & Bath Works candles.

FAQs:

Why Do Yankee Candles Not Smell Anymore?

Sometimes when the candles are ancient and not burned for quite some time, they lose their scent. This causes them to either stop working or lose some of their efficiency. The same might be the case with Yankee candles. Keep the lid with these candles and use them to cover it, as this can help retain their efficiency for a better smell.

What Brand Of Candle Has The Strongest Scent?

Many candle brands have a strong smell and even more long-lasting burn time with a better smell than both Yankee and Body & Works candles. We have Boy Smell by Kush, Soul Care by KEYS, Maison Louise Marie No.3, Athena Club by Athena, and many more.

Do Yankee Candles Make The Room Smell Nice?

Yankee candles have the potential to make your room smell lovely and aromatic by just continuously burning them for a couple of hours only. This will circulate the scent in all the areas, making the smell pleasant and soothing. Since these candles come in jar containers with a large diameter, it helps more in throwing scent in a better way to every corner around the room.

What Makes Yankee Candles Smell So Good?

The Yankee candles smell beautiful as they add fragrances and additives to their wax material and mix them well to give their candle a unique scent. Using natural essential oils and fragrance extracts with refined Paraffin wax gives more burn time at a slower rate in their scents. This is what makes their candles smell lovely and beautiful.

Conclusion:

Both candles have their perks of buying and are second to none in terms of quality or performance. Yankee candles might be a good choice for those looking for a wide variety, size variations, slow burn time, and not too strong a scent effect. 

However, BBW candles offer a limited range, fast burn time, and deep aromatic fragrances with a strong impact that quickly spreads to every corner of your place. Therefore, we leave the decision to the reader to decide what best suits their candle needs according to their moods or preferences.